Turn First Time Readers into Fans with Your Writing

Turn First Time Blog Readers into

In the age of Pinterest and Facebook, gorgeous photography and attention-grabbing graphics pull more new visitors to your blog than ever before.  Unfortunately, too many of those opportunities become one and done visits, instead of translating into long-term readership.  While visuals are an invaluable way to get your foot in the door, well-crafted writing can get you invited inside for a drink.  There are few simple ways to woo those new readers and turn them into fans, followers, or customers.  So, settle in, turn on some Barry White, and  learn how simple post structure can make sure that your new readers just can’t get enough of your blog, baaaayyy-beh.

The introduction of your post becomes like a blind date with your new reader.  You don’t know them, they don’t know you, but matchmaker Pinterest thought you guys would really hit it off, so here you both are.  As with any blind date, you want to make a great first impression.  In your introduction, you will want to create interest  and put your best foot forward.

  1. Create Interest – Grab your reader’s attention with a strong first paragraph.  Identify the main idea to be discussed in the post and provide a reason why the reader should be interested in reading it.  This is especially important if you truncate your posts, because this first paragraph will be all that shows up on your blog’s main page.
  2. Put your Best Foot Forward – Just like you wouldn’t meet your blind date in pajama pants and with unbrushed teeth, you don’t want your reader’s first experience with your writing to be full of grammatical errors.  Be sure to give special attention to your first few paragraphs when proofreading.

Now that your blind date has gone well, it’s time to get more serious with your reader.  If you’ve got them reading past the first few paragraphs of the post, you might as well be sharing a phosphate through two straws and wearing each other’s class rings.  You’re going steady.  In the body of the post, you and your reader are more comfortable with each other, so it’s time to connect and let your true self shine.

  1. Make the Reader Feel a Connection – Even though you can’t have a back and forth conversation with your reader with a blog post, you can still make your reader feel like the prettiest girl at the dance.  Pepper your post with relatable experiences: stories about the challenges of motherhood, go on a short tangent about your love for chocolate, make a reference to popular culture, etc.  If you can get your reader to smile, and think, “Oh, I feel that way too,” you’ve just made a huge stride towards making that reader a blog follower.
  2. Be Yourself – Just like your mother told you when you were young, people are going to love you for you, and if they don’t, it wasn’t meant to be.  Don’t try to be SO accommodating and relatable that you lose all sense of self.  Be authentic and your readers will respond to that.

It’s finally time.  The reader has made it all the way through your blog post.  They’ve laughed, they’ve cried.  They’re starting to think that you might be The One.  It’s time to pop the question.  Every blog post should end with a call to action.  It probably shouldn’t be as blatant as getting down on one knee and telling your reader that they will make you the happiest blogger in the world by subscribing to your RSS feed, but you should still give them a way to connect further.  Invite them to:

  1. Share the Post  – Whether you include a sentence encouraging your readers to share the post via social media or just provide social sharing buttons on each post, there should be a clear way for readers to show others your awesome content.
  2. Check Out Similar Posts – Again, you can include interior links or thumbnails to relevant content or install a related content widget.
  3. Become a Follower – It’s a bold move, but if you’re brave you can suggest that your readers follow your blog feed or social media accounts at the end of a post.  Once again, this can be written into the post itself or accomplished through a blog widget.

IMPROVE TODAY:  Analyze your last five blog posts.  Do they contain an interesting introduction, an authentically written body, and a clear call to action?  Where can you improve?

If you are looking to improve your blog writing skills even further, check out my e-book Mad Writing Skills: A Non-threatening Guide to Grammar and Writing for the Creative Blogger. 

Jessica Hill
I’m Jessica Hill, the slightly-unbalanced blogger of Mad in Crafts. I used to spend my days teaching Shakespeare and Longfellow to high school students, trying desperately to make the classics modern for my students… or at least to keep them awake for the 45 minute class period. Now, I teach readers how to combine classic style with modern trends in decorating, DIY, cooking, writing, and more! And hopefully you stay awake in the meantime!
Jessica Hill
Jessica Hill


  1. This is great advice!!

  2. These are such great tips! Thanks for sharing how all parts of the post contribute to that reader-blogger relationship. I think that is key.
    I’ve really been working more on the body of the post – adding those personal tidbits. I think that it gives new readers something to connect to, but also gives long-time readers more insight into the “gal behind the blog.” Which is probably a good thing. Sometimes. 😉
    ps …I’m totally hearing “I can’t get enough of your blog baby” being sung in my head right now. 😉

  3. Terrific advice. Thanks so much for sharing!

  4. Such Great and Valid information here. The opening statement really says a lot. I often find myself popping over to a page that had an AWESOME image but wasn’t grabbed in by the content. This a great reminder for myself, what I put in Verbally should be just as attention grabbing as my images. Thanks for the reminders.

  5. Great advice! Thanks for sharing it! :)


  6. Such great information! Time for me to go back and read some of my posts…and maybe make a few changes :) Life to the full! Melissa @ DaisyMaeBelle

  7. Thanks for the tips!!


  1. […] Great writing tips for bloggers. […]

Leave a Reply

Read previous post:
Olympic Confetti Gold Medals

The 2014 Winter Olympics are just around the corner, so I'm here to show you how make confetti gold medals....